subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite mapBuy a Classified
Sat, Nov 07 2009 

Published: February 09, 2009 09:11 am    print this story  

Family planning is essential

By Stephen Dick
CNHI News Service

The right-wing attack machine went into overdrive last week after House Speaker Nancy Pelosi dared to defend funds for family planning in the House’s stimulus bill.

Pelosi told ABC’s “This Week” that the promotion of contraceptives and family planning will reduce government costs by preventing unwanted pregnancies.

That should be common sense, but you would’ve thought that she advocated the neutering of all newborn males. Conservative scolds took her to task, mostly based on religious objections to family planning.

Charges of Nazi-style eugenics and China’s one-child policy poisoned the debate with no grounding in reality. MSNBC’s Chris Matthews said, “(W)hy should the federal government have a policy of reducing the number of births?”

CNN’s Jack Cafferty said, “That’s starting to sound a little like Chairman Mao.”

Brian Sussman told KFSO radio in San Francisco: “She’s talking about in-the-womb genocide here.”

Once again, faced with manufactured controversy from ideologues, the Democrats backed down and removed family-planning funds from the bill. It’s a shame to see the Democrats continue to cave in to right-wing thugs’ scare tactics. Wasn’t this cowardice supposed to end with the election of Barack Obama?

Andrea Tantaros, a political commentator on Fox News, said, “Show me an economist that says we are in an economic crisis because of birth-control shortage.”

It’s typical that people who object to family planning (or any other kind of planning) are looking about five minutes down the road instead of decades. In the long run, policies such as the one Pelosi promotes will indeed cut costs, in health care, unemployment and other services needed by people marginalized by unfettered capitalism.

The world cannot sustain unlimited population growth. Where will the food and water come from? Where will the jobs come from with resources in decline?

US News and World Reports quotes Phil Longman in his book “Empty Cradle”: Population growth is a major source of economic growth: More people create more demand for the products capitalists sell and more supply of the labor capitalists buy ... a decline in the number of workers implies a decline in an economy’s potential growth.”

This is nonsense on so many counts. At the current level of population, there is hunger, homelessness, poverty and lack of jobs.

All of these will increase exponentially as population rises.

Companies seek more efficiency and productivity without increasing labor costs. So all those people from the population boom aren’t going to get jobs. Longman doesn’t consider this. His classic economic model discounts the fact that capitalists try to get the most done with the least people.

The only way people can buy from capitalists is if they have living-wage jobs. But it’s more important for capitalists to maintain profits than jobs. Still, all those people who can’t work will need to live.

What happens with increasing demand for resources from an overpopulated world? There will be riots in the streets (remember “Soylent Green”?) just for food and water. Government costs will have to escalate to help those left out by capitalism.

Family planning and a reduction of population is absolutely essential to the survival of the planet. The scare tactics involving eugenics and one-child laws only give people an opportunity to keep their heads in the sand about long-term problems. A national family planning and contraceptive policy only makes sense and serves as a firm rejection of an octuplet mentality that too many people accept.

Stephen Dick writes for The Herald Bulletin in Anderson, Ind., a CNHI newspaper. He can be reached at steve.dick@heraldbulletin.com.

print this story  

Photos


Stephen Dick mug shot None/John Cleary/The Herald Bulletin (Click for larger image)



autoconx
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Premier Guide
Premium Jobs

CMA needed for fast-paced nephrology
CMA needed for fast-paced nephrology office. Send resume to:
Richmond Nephrology & Hypertension
793 Eastern B
...>MORE

Lexington Herald Leader has a morning
Lexington Herald Leader has a morning route available in Mt. Vernon/Brodhead. Takes approx 3 hrs daily, w/profit potenti...>MORE

Now Hiring Shift Mgr & Asst Mgr
Now Accepting Resume/Applicantions for > Shift Manager
> & Assistant Manager. Apply at Madison
Gardens, 152
...>MORE

Employment Opportunity Construction Helper
Employment Opportunity Construction Helper
10 temp. positions. Bobby Cameron Stone Masonry, Brodhead, KY. Employmen
...>MORE

Appalachian Research & Defense Fund
Appalachian Research & Defense Fund of Kentucky, Inc. is accepting resumes for two full-time intake secretaries. The app...>MORE

Now Taking Applications for all Positions.
Now Taking Applications for all Positions. Apply in person. Madison Gardens, 152 N. Madison Ave., downtown Richmond....>MORE

See all ads

Premium Autos

Looking for a Great Auto Deal?
Looking to buy or sell? Check here for the Premium Auto Section. For More Information Call 859-624-6681. ...>MORE

2003 Wildwood, 37ft S/C. Like new. Air,
2003 Wildwood, 37ft S/C. Like new. Air, awning, super slide. Fully loaded. Must go. Paid $28,000 asking $17,000 Best of...>MORE

1998 Chevrolet Cavalier.
1998 Chevrolet Cavalier.
111K mi. Good condition. $1800.
859-623-0685
...>MORE

See all ads

Premium Rentals

For Sale 3 bdrm, 2 ba, 16x80 Mobile Home
For Sale 3 bdrm, 2 ba, 16x80 Mobile Home with storage building. On Mobile home lot in Bayberry Tr Pk Behind E.W.James ne...>MORE

Duplex for rent. 115 Leimar Drive. 3Bd,
Duplex for rent. 115 Leimar Drive. 3Bd, 2ba, FR, bsmt, deck. $675mo.
859-369-1040, 626-2564.
...>MORE

Do you need Affordabe Housing?
Do you need
Affordable housing?
Richmond Manor Apts.
743 N. 3rd Street.,
is accepting applica
...>MORE

See all ads

Deal of the Day

Everything from A-Z!!!
Need to sell your bedroom suite, washer and dryer, or even selling an animal? Call Mayme or Melissa at 859-624-6681 to p...>MORE

See all ads


 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2009. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index