A water management and construction company is suing the Richmond Utility Board claiming the entity has not paid its bill for the 2012 repair of a water pump.
Layne Heavy Civil Inc. filed the suit Feb. 25 in Madison Circuit Court. A division of the global company Layne Christensen, Layne Heavy Civil works with with government and industrial clients to oversee design and construction of water and wastewater treatment plants and pipeline installations, according to the company’s website.
Layne’s complaint states representatives of the company were present in 2008 to supervise the installation and start up of two new water pumps at the Richmond plant.
In 2009, Richmond Utilities notified Layne that the motor oil in the pump units had turned red. The utility asked Layne to change the oil, according to the court document.
Layne agreed to perform the oil change, and the complaint states Richmond Utilities ordered the motor oil that Layne use to perform the job.
However, in September 2011, Pump Unit 2 failed, and Richmond Utilities asked Layne to submit a proposal to fix the pump, which included replacement, repair, labor, equipment and material costs, the company said in its complaint.
Layne submitted a proposal Nov. 16, 2011, which was accepted, and the work was completed Jan. 5, 2012, the water management company stated.
Layne billed Richmond Utilities $70,641 for the repair work, but after “numerous requests,” no payment was received, according to the complaint.
“Richmond’s representatives gave a number of excuses for the failure to pay the original invoice and eventually claimed that Richmond was excused from paying the amount owed to Layne because Richmond believed that Layne had caused the failure of the pump by installing the incorrect oil in the motors in 2009,” the complaint stated.
Layne claims the accusation is “unfounded” in part because the type of failure the water pump experienced was not related to the motor bearings. Also, even if the wrong oil was used, that was the fault of Richmond Utilities because Layne used the oil Richmond had ordered, according to the complaint.
On April 17, Layne agreed to give Richmond Utilities credits totaling $15,274 and submitted a revised invoice of $55,366. Although an email included with the lawsuit indicates that Richmond was willing to pay the revised bill, Layne said no payment had been received.
Layne is asking for either the $70,641 amount or $55,366, plus interest and attorney fees.
No reply to the complaint has been filed by Richmond Utilities. Defendants typically have 30 days in which to file a response.
Lakeshore Engineering federal lawsuit
The Richmond Utilities Board also was sued in federal court in April by a Michigan company that performed work on the Otter Creek Wastewater Treatment Plant. Lakeshore Engineering claimed that it was misled by the site’s flawed geotechnical report and incurred significant extra costs in constructing 12 miles of pipeline.
Lakeshore stated that Richmond Utilities owed the company nearly half a million on its final contract balance. The two entities tried to work out the issue in mediation in March 2012, but the effort failed, leading to the civil lawsuit.
Richmond Utilities responded June 22 to Lakeshore’s complaint, denying the allegations and making a counterclaim for nearly $500,000 in “unliquidated damages” caused by Lakeshore’s failure to “substantially and finally complete its work under the Agreement in a timely manner.”
No additional court documents have been filed in the case since July 30, according to Pacer, the federal court system’s online filing system.
Sarah Hogsed can be reached at shogsed@
- Local News
Man indicted in January police chase
A Madison grand jury has indicted a Richmond man in connection with a vehicle chase that resulted in the lockdown of two schools in early January.
Heroin found in card sent to jail
An investigation began Wednesday afternoon at the Madison County Detention Center when a jail employee found heroin in a piece of mail destined for a prisoner.
Back to Broadway!
Directed by Eddie Kennedy and Lisa Scully, the Berea Arena performance is a musical revue featuring talented voices performing the best-loved songs of Broadway.
Murder indictment issued in vehicular assault case
A Madison grand jury indicted a Richmond man on a murder charge Wednesday in the death of his girlfriend’s brother, who he is alleged to have struck with his car.
Jeremy D. Rice, 21, also was indicted as a second-degree persistent felony offender, according to court documents.
4,000 march, remember in Frankfort
This time the welcome was warmer; still cold, but the sun shone; and 50 years of progress were marked.
It was different, cold and rainy, and the welcome by the white establishment was just as chilly 50 years ago when 10,000 marched on the state Capitol seeking passage of a public accommodations law.
‘Fairness’ ordinance cost debated
Berea’s City Council and Mayor Steve Connelly met for two hours Tuesday afternoon to discuss proposed changes to the city’s anti-discrimination ordinance.
HVAC tools reported stolen from van
A representative of Robert White Refrigeration, West Irvine Street, reported Thursday that several tools had been stolen from one of the company vehicles while it was parked at the Richmond Mall about noon Dec. 4.
Berea man blames city for flooding
North Powell Street resident Hubert Chasteen Jr. appeared Tuesday evening before the Berea City Council to address flooding on his Pinnacle Street property.
Board takes no action on softball fields
Richmond Mayor Jim Barnes made clear during a discussion about Irvine-McDowell Park at Tuesday’s park board meeting that he wants the city’s girls’ softball fields relocated to Lake Reba park.
Paula Deen coming for St. Mark benefit tea
Paula Deen, the cook, author and entrepreneur known for her southern-style food, will make a personal appearance in Lexington on Memorial Day, May 26, hosted by Richmond’s St. Mark Catholic Parish.
Deen will be the special guest for tea and conversation at the Carrick House, 312 N. Limestone St., in downtown Lexington.
“The tea will begin at the ‘proper’ time – half past 2 – and guests will enjoy a lovely afternoon featuring traditional foods, such as scones, small cakes, cookies and finger sandwiches,” said Father James Sichko, pastor of St. Mark Parish. “I think everyone will enjoy the conversation, too!”
- More Local News Headlines
- Man indicted in January police chase