The Richmond Register

Local News

January 5, 2014

Ky. Supreme Court upholds guilty verdicts

For 2010 sex crime, burglary

RICHMOND — The Kentucky Supreme Court has upheld the conviction of a man sentenced by a Madison County jury to 35 years in prison for first-degree burglary and sodomy.

Sotoy Minter, 34, was found guilty March 28, 2012, of raping another man following a three-day trial. His sentence was enhanced because he already had a felony conviction on his record.

Minter argued in his appeal to the state supreme court that Madison Circuit Judge Jean C. Logue incorrectly denied his motion for a directed verdict on the burglary charge, the trial court should have allowed testimony about the victim’s past sexual activity and the court should not have allowed the persistent-felony offender charge to be added to his original indictment.

At his trial, Minter testified that the encounter with the victim, who was his neighbor, on Jan. 15, 2010, was consensual. The victim testified that he attended a neighborhood party but was helped back to his apartment by his girlfriend and Minter later that night because he was intoxicated.

The victim said he awoke later to find Minter on top of him, forcibly having anal intercourse with him. The victim contacted the police afterward and was taken to the emergency room for treatment of his injuries.

DNA samples taken from the victim were a match for Minter, according to court testimony from investigating officers.

Minter stated in his appeal that the judge should have issued a directed verdict of not guilty on the first-degree burglary charge at trial because the state had not proved he had the “intent to commit a crime” when he entered the home. Minter testified that he believed the victim had invited him to come back later for sexual intercourse.

The supreme court affirmed the Madison judge’s decision to not grant a directed verdict based on the victim’s testimony he hadn’t invited Minter to his apartment, repeatedly asked him to leave and did not consent to the sexual encounter.

“The physical evidence of (the victim’s) injuries provides circumstantial evidence supporting the Commonwealth’s case,” the supreme court wrote.

The supreme court also ruled that the Madison court properly barred testimony about the victim’s past sexual history based upon Kentucky’s Rape Shield Law (KRE 412) and because it was hearsay.

Minter argued that the victim may have engaged in homosexual acts in the past and was lying about what happened to conceal his sexual orientation from his girlfriend. Therefore, evidence about the victim’s sexual history should have been presented at trial.

Only three exceptions exist for allowing an alleged victim’s sexual history to be presented at a rape trial, and none of those exceptions applied in this case, according to the supreme court. It did not prove another person was the source of the DNA evidence, as Minter admitted to having sexual contact with the victim; it did not prove consent based on prior sexual contact between the two men, as none was alleged; and testimony about the victim’s sexual history with either men or women did not pertain directly to the offense charged, the court ruled.

“There is no doubt that KRE 412 operates to shield putative victims from disclosure of prior sexual behaviors that have no relevance to the offense on trial except to cast a negative light upon the alleged victim,” the opinion stated. “The purpose of the rule and the language of the rule allow for no differentiation between heterosexual behavior and homosexual behavior.”

Finally, even though the persistent-felony offender charge was added to Minter’s indictment after the burglary and sodomy charges, the Madison court properly allowed it to proceed to trial, the supreme court ruled.

The court’s opinion in the Minter case has been published, meaning it can be applied to court cases in Kentucky that pose similar legal questions.

Sarah Hogsed can be reached at shogsed@richmondregister.com or 624-6694.

1
Text Only
Local News
  • Miss Madison Winners 2.jpg My fair ladies

      

    July 29, 2014 5 Photos

  • 10th Quilt Extravaganza is Friday, Saturday

    Displays of quilts by men, baby quilts, the Grandmother’s Flower Garden pattern, an exhibit of feed sack fabric, ongoing demonstrations, and a vendors market are features of the 10th Berea Quilt Extravaganza Friday and Saturday at Berea Community School off Ellipse Street.

    July 29, 2014

  • 7-30 Samantha Frederick.jpg RPD: Heroin sales lead to trafficking indictment

    Executing a warrant issued after Samantha Frederick, 29, Northgate Drive, was indicted July 16 by a Madison County grand jury, Richmond Police arrested her Monday on drug trafficking charges.

    July 29, 2014 1 Photo

  • 7-29 YMCA-Schools.jpg YMCA, county district to provide after-school care

    The Telford YMCA is partnering with the Madison County School District to provide after-school child care for kindergarten and elementary students.
    YMCA Executive Director Dave Wallace and Madison County School Superintendent Elmer Thomas announced the partnership Monday afternoon.

    July 29, 2014 1 Photo

  • 7-29 Lucille May 1.jpg Memories bloom in May’s garden

    After realizing a story was being written about 96-year-old Lucille May, tenants of Willis Manor gathered in the lobby to share stories about her.
    Affectionately called “Mamaw” by other residents and workers at the apartment building, May has spent the four years of her residence transforming an outdoor garden that was overtaken by weeds. It’s now a thriving flowerbed, complete with interesting rocks, decorations and conversation.

    July 29, 2014 4 Photos

  • 7-29 Construction 1.jpg Water Street storm-water digging begins

    Caisson holes were drilled and then filled with concrete and steel poles Monday to create a retaining structure to shore up the Allstate Insurance building foundations' firm when excavation for the Water Street Stormwater Improvement Project begins.
    Digging for 20 ton, 6 by 7 foot concrete box culverts will begin today, if weather permits, said Jason Hart, Richmond’s director of Planning and Zoning. The culverts will help reduce the likelihood of flooding on Water Street by carrying storm water under Main Street, the CVS parking lot and Irvine Street to a stream, he said.

    July 28, 2014 4 Photos

  • 7-29 Robert Abney.jpg RPD: Bottle bomb injures man, damages neighbor’s home

    Richmond Police on Friday charged Robert Abney, 30, of Moberly Avenue, in connection with a May 30 explosion that injured Abney and damaged a neighbor’s home.
    Officers were dispatched May 30 to a residence in the 500 block of Moberly Avenue to investigate the report of an explosion.
    They found the remains of a plastic bottle bomb near a residence adjoining Moberly’s, according to an RPD news release. A wall of the occupied home was smoldering and grass was burned in the area, it added.

    July 28, 2014 4 Photos

  • 7-29 Steven Coffey.jpg Two led police on I-75 chase from Berea

    Berea Police found a man passed out and intoxicated inside his crashed vehicle on Interstate 75 Wednesday, according to a police report.
    Steven Coffey, 34, of Berea, had slurred speech and was unsteady on his feet when officers arrived at the vehicle, the police report stated. They determined he was under the influence of drugs, the report stated.

    July 28, 2014 2 Photos

  • 7-27 HeartChase 1.jpg A race to the finish line

    Sheltered by overcast sky and supported by a cool breeze, teams competed Saturday morning in the second annual HeartChase at Richmond Centre.

    July 26, 2014 6 Photos

  • 7-27 Hops 1.jpg Hops & Vine Festival raises money for humane society

    Downtown Richmond’s Hops and Vine Festival started more than two years ago with a question.

    July 26, 2014 3 Photos