The Richmond Register

Local News

November 28, 2011

Supreme Court hears GPS use argument

RICHMOND — The evolving capabilities of technology has the U.S. Supreme Court debating whether the warrantless use of GPS trackers is a violation of the Fourth Amendment right to privacy.

Some Madison County law enforcement agencies have admitted to using them in the past without first obtaining a warrant.

The case heard Nov. 8 by the court was about Antoine Jones, a Washington, D.C., man who was trailed by the FBI via a Global Positioning System tracker. He was convicted in 2008 for allegedly possessing and distributing more than 50 kilograms of cocaine.

Most of the evidence used in court derived from the use of the GPS tracker, and Jones received a life sentence.

Last year, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia sided with Jones and disagreed that federal agents have the right to do covert, 24-hour monitoring of a person’s whereabouts.

The appellate court maintained that evidence gathered in the case was a violation of the Fourth Amendment.

During the hearing, Michael R. Dreeben, deputy solicitor general for the Department of Justice, tried to convince the nine justices that the GPS use in the case did not violate Jones’ right to privacy.

Dreeben’s argument included references to Kate v. United States and Knotts v. United States, both cases where the right to privacy was questioned.

“Since the court’s decision in Katz v. United States, the court has recognized a basic dichotomy under the Fourth Amendment,” Dreeben said, according to a hearing transcript. “What a person seeks to preserve as private in the enclave of his own home or in a private letter or inside of his vehicle when he is traveling is a subject of Fourth Amendment protection. But what he reveals to the world, such as his movements in a car on a public roadway, is not.”

In Knotts v. United States, the court ruled that visual and beeper surveillance of a vehicle traveling on the public roadways infringed no Fourth Amendment expectation of privacy, Dreeben said.

Chief Justice John G. Roberts argued that both cases were too dated to be held parallel to Jones’ case.

“That was 30 years ago,” Roberts said. “The technology is very different and you get a lot more information from the GPS surveillance than you do from following a beeper ... That’s a lot of work to follow the car. They’ve got to listen to the beeper; when they lose it they have got to call in the helicopter. Here they just sit back in the station and ... push a button whenever they want to find out where the car is. They look at data from a month and find out everywhere it’s been in the past month. That seems to be dramatically different.”

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg summarized Dreeben’s argument by saying he was suggesting that someone’s residence is the only “private” place.

“... that is the end point of your argument, that an electronic device, as long as it’s not used inside the house, is OK,” she said.

Justice Stephen Breyer voiced his concerns about the possibilities which could be created by Jones’ conviction.

“... if you win this case then there is nothing to prevent the police or the government from monitoring 24 hours a day the public movement of every citizen of the United States,” Breyer said.

Dreeben did not agree.

“This case does not involve universal surveillance of every member of this court or every member of the society,” he said. “It involves limited surveillance of somebody who was suspected of drug activity... This court has said that trespass is neither necessary nor sufficient to create a Fourth Amendment violation.”

Stephen C. Leckar, Jones’ attorney, claimed Jones’ person data was seized during the police’s investigation.

“Data is seized that is created by the GPS. Antoine Jones has the right, Your Honor, to control the use of his vehicle. And what the government did was ... deprive him of the use of that ... society does not view as reasonable the concept that the United States government has the right to take a device that enables them to engage in pervasive, limitless, cost-free surveillance, that completely replaces the human equation,” Leckar said.

Madison County Commonwealth’s Attorney David Smith of Richmond said he is glad to hear the Supreme Court is going to be taking up the issue.

“I think both sides have very good arguments,” he said. “I think law enforcement has every right to observe where you go (in public), but I don’t think people expect their movements to be monitored 24 hours a day, seven days a week. You don’t want to unnecessarily hamper law enforcement, but I don’t think people are comfortable with a Big Brother concept where someone can monitor you 24 hours a day.”

A 2009 Richmond Register investigation discovered that several local law enforcement agencies had possession of and/or were using GPS devices in local criminal investigations without obtaining warrants.

The Central Kentucky Area Drug Task Force, a joint agency comprised of officers from the Madison, Clark, Garrard and Jackson sheriff’s offices and the Berea Police Department, spent nearly $18,000 several years ago to purchase a variety of systems designed to allow officers to track the movement of vehicles covertly using GPS satellites.

Former task force director Rick Johnson confirmed in a 2009 interview that his agency owns three of the devices, and has used them, but declined to give any specific details beyond stating that they were installed without obtaining warrants.

He maintained that it was legal for the trackers to be placed on vehicles parked on public property.

Richmond Police Chief Larry Brock confirmed his department owned more than one of the devices, but said they were purchased “long before” he became chief in July 2007.

“We do have and utilize tracking devices in certain, very specific, cases,” Brock said in 2009. “They may be deployed in such cases where it has been established through credible information that the target is involved in criminal activity. They are not used routinely and are never utilized against law-abiding citizens in any form or fashion.”

Ronica Shannon can be reached at rshannon@

richmondregister.com or 624-6608.

1
Text Only
Local News
  • 2-11 Mangan.jpeg Man indicted in I-75 wreck that killed two

    A man who police believe started the chain of events that led to the deaths of two people on Interstate 75 in February was indicted on several felony charges Wednesday in Madison Circuit Court.
    Bryan M. Mangan, 56, of South Bend, Ind., was indicted on six counts of first-degree wanton endangerment, tampering with physical evidence and operating on a suspended license.

    April 24, 2014 2 Photos

  • Man charged with reselling employer’s equipment

    A man who worked for a local satellite TV company has been charged with ordering extra equipment and selling it online.
    Charles William Hensley, 39, of Manchester, worked for the Multiband Corporation at its Richmond office, according to a Richmond police report.
    Multiband maintains DIRECTV’s installations, service and upgrades for single-family homes in 20 states and commercial sites nationwide.

    April 24, 2014

  • Saturday is National Drug Take-Back Day

    A nationwide initiative to dispose of prescription drugs in a safe manner will take place Saturday.
    Three Madison County sites are available for residents to get rid of their unused, unneeded or expired prescription drugs as part of the eighth annual National Prescription Drug Take-Back Day:
    • Richmond Police Department, 1721 Lexington Road, box is outside by the front door.
    • Kentucky State Police Post 7, 699 Eastern Bypass, across from the EKU stadium, box is inside at the front door.

    April 24, 2014

  • 4-25 Revue 1.JPG Retro Radio Revue

    “Stan O’Donnell’s Retro Radio Revue,” presented by Rose Barn Theatre, will be performed at 7:30 p.m. Friday and Saturday at Gillum’s Sports Lounge in the Richmond Mall.
    The production focuses on the performers of the show and the follies and chaos that take place as the unexpected ensues. Local musical performers from Madison County will be showcased throughout the production.
    Gillum’s will provide a full menu service and cash bar beginning at 5:30 p.m.
    Tickets for the show are $15 and available at the door or in advance at www.rosebarntheatre.org.
    The event is a fundraiser for the nonprofit arts organization.

    April 24, 2014 3 Photos

  • 4-25 Crit Luallen.jpg Luallen says no to 2015 governor’s race

    After months of deliberation, former state Auditor of Public Accounts Crit Luallen announced Thursday she will sit out the 2015 race for governor.
    The announcement disappointed friends and associates who see Luallen as an able and experienced administrator — she served in six gubernatorial administrations — but also someone with the character and integrity to restore confidence in government.

    April 24, 2014 1 Photo

  • Blue Grass Army Depot sponsors 5K

    The Blue Grass Army Depot is hosting a 5K run/walk Saturday in support of National Sexual Assault Awareness Month.
    The no-entry-fee event will begin and end at the depot’s new sports complex ball fields, according to a news release from the installation. Preregistration is available online at www.bluegrass.army.mil or starting at 9 a.m. the day of the event.

    April 24, 2014

  • 4-24 UKatWaco1.jpg Wildcats encourage Cardinals to work hard in school

    University of Kentucky student athletes Kastine Evans, a guard on the women’s basketball team, and Jon Hood, a guard on the men’s team, stopped by Waco Elementary School on Wednesday to talk about the benefits of working hard in school.

    April 23, 2014 4 Photos

  • Mayor, commissioner pay changed

    The Richmond City Commission approved 4-1 a new pay scale for the mayor and commissioners at a special-called meeting Wednesday morning.

    April 23, 2014

  • 4-24 Lorenzo McWilliams.jpg Harrodsburg to get old Richmond police mobile computers

    Richmond is donating to the city of Harrodsburg eight of 39 old computers formerly used in police cruisers.

    April 23, 2014 1 Photo

  • 4-24 HOSAblooddrive.jpg Health science students organize blood drive

    Aside from the gift cards and free snacks, 50 Madison County high school students have other reasons for donating 35 pints of blood Wednesday to the Kentucky Blood Center at Madison Central High School.

    April 23, 2014 1 Photo

AP Video
Raw: Obama Tours Gyeongbok Palace Swimmer Michael Phelps Back in Competition Raw: Obama Lays Korean War Memorial Wreath Obama Leads Naturalization Ceremony in Seoul Calif. School Bus Crash Hurts Driver, 11 Kids Country Club for Exotic Cars Little Science Behind 'Pollen Vortex' Prediction US Proposes Pay-for-priority Internet Standards Wife Mourns Chicago Doctor Killed in Afghanistan FDA Proposes Regulations on E-cigarettes Kerry Warns Russia of Expensive New Sanctions Mideast Peace Talks Stall on Hamas Deal Cody Walker Remembers His Late Brother Paul Grieving South Korea Puts Up Yellow Ribbons Raw: Kerry Brings His Dog to Work Raw: Girls Survive Car Crash Into Their Bedroom Three U.S. Doctors Killed by Afghan Security Yankees' Pineda Suspended 10 Games for Pine Tar Colleagues Mourn Death of Doctors in Afghanistan Ukraine Launches Operation Against Insurgents
Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Poll

Should Richmond rezone the southwest corner of Main Street and Tates Creek Avenue to B-1 (Neighborhood Business) with restrictions to allow construction of a financial services office?

Yes
No
     View Results