|
Published: May 23, 2008 07:53 pm
Judge rules in city’s favor
Federal rights lawsuit
By Kelly Foreman
Register News Writer
LEXINGTON —
A federal judge Thursday dismissed a lawsuit against the city of Richmond and one of its police officers which alleged a case of mistaken identity violated her constitutional rights.
Debra L. Wren filed the suit in November 2006, more than a year after an incident in which she claims she was arrested on charges her former sister-in-law with the same first and last name — spelled slightly different — allegedly committed.
U.S. District Judge Jennifer B. Coffman entered the judgment affirming that Richmond Police Detective Rodney Richardson not only acted within his responsibilities based on probable cause, but also that once he realized the mistake, he acted quickly to correct it.
“Obviously we are pleased with the result and the court’s finding that no constitutional violation occurred,” said Charley Cole, attorney for the city and Richardson.
The suit stemmed from a credit card theft and subsequent fraudulent use at a Richmond Redi Mart. The fraud victim identified one of the involved suspects as Debra Wren, whom she had seen that day when she performed a urinalysis for Wren at Madison County Drug Court.
With that name, Richardson obtained a video of the Redi Mart activity and conducted a “mug shot” search for Debra Wren in a police department database, court documents state. A photo of Debra Wren was found in the database because “she had previously been arrested and booked for the felony of theft by unlawful taking (“tbut”)/shoplifting in 2002 — a crime all too similar to the tbut, i.e. theft and fraudulent use of (the victim’s) credit card,” court documents state.
Reportedly, the mug shot photo and video from the Redi Mart seemed to match, so Richardson swore out a warrant for Wren’s arrest. After being served with the arrest warrant by another RPD officer, Wren complained she was wrongfully accused and that it was her former sister-in-law who was to blame.
“The facts as developed in discovery clearly indicated that Detective Richardson had probable cause to support the arrest of Debra Wren,” Cole said Friday. “Once it was realized that there were two Debra Wrens (Debra L. Wren and Debora K. Wren) in the city of Richmond, the record reveals that Detective Richardson immediately took action to secure the release of Debra (L.) Wren.”
Coffman agreed.
“Viewing the evidence in the light most favorable to the plaintiff, the court finds that the warrant for Debra Wren’s arrest was supported by probable cause,” Coffman’s ruling states. “... Thus, the plaintiff’s arrest and detention were also supported by probable cause. Therefore, the plaintiff’s constitutional rights were not violated by the actions of the city of Richmond or Detective Richardson.”
Attorney for Wren, Brian Canupp, is not convinced.
“Anytime a person is wrongfully incarcerated it creates a difficult situation for all those involved,” Canupp said. “We disagree with the judgment that was entered by the court in the matter of Wren v. City of Richmond. At this time, it has not been possible to do a thorough review of the opinion with Ms. Wren and to discuss her options, including a request to reconsider the decision or file a direct appeal to the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals.”
“We do not anticipate an appeal,” Cole said, “but we feel confident that the judgment would be affirmed by the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals.”
Kelly Foreman can be reached at kforeman@richmondregister.com or 624-6694.
• Click to discuss this story with other readers on our forums.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
CDL Driver Needed
Immediate opening for CDL Driver, Local Delivery. Apply in person 84 Lumber Richmond No Phone C...>MORE
Mystery Shoppers/Restaurants
Mystery Shopper part-time,visit area Restaurants,and get paid for your visit & expenses.No start up costs.Please tell us...>MORE
Now Hiring Classified Sales Position
Excellent Opportunity The Richmond Register is accepting resume for a Classified Sales position. Candidate must possess...>MORE
Now Hiring
OFFICE ASSISTANT Casual, part time office help needed near downtown Richmond. Telephone, general office activities...>MORE
Needing Teachers & Assistants
Growing Place Child Care Ctr. Now hiring Teachers and Assistant Teachers. Only qualified candidates need to apply. Send...>MORE
Post Office Now Hiring!
POST OFFICE NOW HIRING! Ave Pay $20/hr or $57-Kyr incl fed benefits & OT. Placed by Ad Source ...>MORE
See all ads |
|
1995 Toylota Corolla
1995 Toyota Corolla, 4 cyl, 4 door, power windows, air, FM cassette, 5disc CD changer, sunroof, 26 mi to gallon, $2999. ...>MORE
1967 Plymouth Belvedere for sale
For Sale 1967 Plymouth Belvedere, 4 door, 318 Engine, Maroon Fully Restorable, $4,500 obo. Respond by 7-21-0...>MORE
1978 White Elcamino with topper. 350 Double hump head engine, original Rally wheels. $1700 neg. Good running condition. ...>MORE
See all ads |
|
1 & 3 bdrm Apt for rent
1 & 3 Bdrm Apts For rent All utilities Paid. Including cable & Internet. Call 623-8963....>MORE
2 bdrm house on Slate Lick Rd Berea
2 bdrm home, Slate Lick Rd Berea $350 mo $100 dep. No pets. 1 yr lease. 986-1400. leave message....>MORE
Clearence Sale on 8 new homes
Foreclosure Over load Sale 6 left in Stock. First come first serve must sale cheap. Call 859-623-8404....>MORE
See all ads |
|
Everything from A-Z!!!
Need to sell your bedroom suite, washer and dryer, or even selling an animal? Call Mayme or Melissa at 859-624-6681 to p...>MORE
See all ads |
|
 |
|