The Richmond Register

Crime

October 29, 2012

State appeals court upholds ruling in drug possession case

RICHMOND — The Kentucky Court of Appeals has ruled that a Richmond man had no reasonable expectation of privacy in the area surrounding his mobile home in a case where a Richmond officer saw him handling cocaine through the home’s window.

Javier Cruz-Vazquez, 32, was charged March 20, 2010, with first-degree trafficking in a controlled substance, second-degree possession of a controlled substance and possession of drug paraphernalia.

Two Richmond police officers, Alfred Gray and Joseph Lain, were on foot patrol that night in the Williams Mobile Home Park on Big Hill Avenue, according to the appeals court ruling that was handed down Oct. 5.

After finishing their foot patrol, the officers took a short cut through the grassy area between two trailers to return to their vehicle, the ruling stated. While walking between the homes, Gray reported seeing Cruz-Vasquez “manipulating items” through a window that appeared to be cocaine and a plastic bag. Although the blinds were drawn, Gray said he could see into the trailer through a gap in the blinds and the bottom of the window seal, according to the ruling.

The officers knocked on Cruz-Vasquez’s door, and when he answered, he was holding the plastic bag, according to the ruling. He dropped the plastic bag and tried to step back into the home, but the officers “grabbed and handcuffed Cruz-Vasquez,” the ruling stated. A warrant was obtained for searching the home and officers reported finding drugs and more paraphernalia.

The plastic bag also tested positive for traces of cocaine, according to the ruling.

Cruz-Vasquez’s attorney made a motion to suppress the arrest and the evidence gathered following the arrest based on the belief that Gray violated the man’s Fourth Amendment rights by looking through the window from the area next to the trailer.

Judge Jean Chenault Logue denied the motion to suppress, and Cruz-Vasquez pleaded guilty to the charges, reserving the right to appeal the ruling. He received a sentence of five years probation.

Two of the three judges on the appeals court panel supported the circuit court’s decision that Cruz-Vasquez’s constitutional rights were not violated. One judge, Janet L. Stumbo, dissented.

Cruz-Vasquez asserted that the area immediately around his rented mobile home was curtilage to his home, giving him a reasonable expectation of privacy in that area. Curtilage is defined as the area immediately surrounding a dwelling, and a home and its curtilage are protected from warrantless search and seizure by the Fourth Amendment.

Madison Circuit Court found that the officers had a legitimate purpose for walking between the trailers, and there is no defined yard for each of the homes, which were very close to each other.

“Based on testimony presented, including photographs, the Court concludes that (Cruz-Vasquez) did not have a reasonable expectation of privacy as to his activity inside the mobile home when his blind was not fully closed,” Judge Logue ruled. “The area between the mobile homes is a common area open to the public, and anyone in the area could have viewed Cruz-Vasquez’s activity.”

In its ruling, the appeals court judges applied a precedent from the U.S. Supreme Court, which has defined four factors when determining if an area near a home is curtilage: “the proximity of the area claimed to be curtilage to the home, whether the area is included within an enclosure surrounding the home, the nature of the uses to which the area is put, and the steps taken by the resident to protect the area from observation by people passing by.”

The evidence presented in the case showed the mobile homes were not enclosed, no signs supported a finding that the area was used for “intimate activities that take place in the home,” and Cruz-Vasquez did not take any measures to protect the area from public observation, the appeals court said in its ruling.

Cruz-Vasquez also argued in his appeal that the officers conducted a warrantless search when they entered his home to detain him and seize the plastic.

However, based on legal precedent, the court ruled that officers do have the right to conduct a warrantless search under certain exigent circumstances.

One of these is if officers have probable cause to believe evidence may be removed or destroyed while waiting for a search warrant.

The appeals’ court ruling in this case was designated “not to be published,” meaning it did not create a legal precedent that can be cited in future cases. However, unpublished decisions contain legal analyses that may be important to judges ruling on similar cases.

Sarah Hogsed can be reached at shogsed@richmondregister.com or 624-6694.

1
Text Only
Crime
  • 7-29 Robert Abney.jpg RPD: Bottle bomb injures man, damages neighbor’s home

    Richmond Police on Friday charged Robert Abney, 30, of Moberly Avenue, in connection with a May 30 explosion that injured Abney and damaged a neighbor’s home.
    Officers were dispatched May 30 to a residence in the 500 block of Moberly Avenue to investigate the report of an explosion.
    They found the remains of a plastic bottle bomb near a residence adjoining Moberly’s, according to an RPD news release. A wall of the occupied home was smoldering and grass was burned in the area, it added.

    July 28, 2014 4 Photos

  • Jailed woman charged with heroin trafficking

    A Richmond woman already jailed on another charge was served with a drug trafficking warrant Thursday.

    July 26, 2014

  • 7-25 William Gilbert.jpg Four arrested on meth charges at Berea motel

    Berea Police arrested four people Wednesday at the Knights Inn on Chestnut Street, including a man they said tried to conceal a meth lab on his person.

    July 24, 2014 5 Photos

  • 7-24 Justin Smith.jpg One arrested, one sought in Sunday home invasion

    Two men in search of another man broke into a Keystone Drive home Sunday and harassed residents in another nearby home Monday, according to a Richmond Police report.

    July 23, 2014 1 Photo

  • RPD: Man falls through ceiling attempting to elude police

    When Richmond Police went to Cody Shelton’s Kristin Drive apartment at 9:44 p.m. Wednesday to arrest him on a parole-violation charge, they said he attempted to elude them by hiding in the attic crawl space.

    July 18, 2014

  • Man indicted in Manhattan Club shooting

    A man charged in a May 20 shooting at the Manhattan Club in which a man was wounded was indicted Wednesday by a Madison County grand jury.

    July 17, 2014

  • 7-18 Aaron Tate.jpg Local burglary suspect found in Texas border town

    A man wanted in Madison County on burglary and criminal mischief charges since March was arrested July 11 by the U.S. Marshal Service in Brownsville, Texas, on the Mexican board.

    July 17, 2014 1 Photo

  • Mother pleads guilty to allowing child rape

    Deanna Lawson, charged with 20 counts of complicity in the rape and sodomy of a minor, pleaded guilty in Madison Circuit Court on Wednesday.
    Between October 2011 and September 2012, Eric Kelley had sexual relations with Lawson’s two daughters, according to court documents.
    She was charged with complicity after police said they learned Lawson knew of the crimes but didn’t try to stop them or alert authorities.

    July 12, 2014

  • No extra jail time for parents on prostitution charge

    Anthony and Kathy Hart, two Madison County residents who pleaded guilty May 21 to prostituting their daughters, won’t be seeing any extra time in jail.
    Both parents, who served time in jail while their charges were pending, were sentenced to probation Thursday in Madison Circuit Court.

    July 11, 2014

  • RPD arrests three on drug charges

    A couple is facing several charges after police said they sold drugs to an undercover officer late last year.
    In December 2013, the Richmond Police Narcotics Unit purchased a quantity of suboxone strips from Ryan Anderson, 30, and Chastity L. King, 28, on two occasions during a covert investigation, according to an RPD news release.

    July 11, 2014

AP Video
Kerry: Humanitarian Cease-fire Efforts Continue Raw: Corruption Trial Begins for Former Va Gov. The Carbon Trap: US Exports Global Warming UN Security Council Calls for Gaza Cease-fire Traditional African Dishes Teach Healthy Eating 13 Struck by Lightning on Calif. Beach Baseball Hall of Famers Inducted Israel, Hamas Trade Fire Despite Truce in Gaza Italy's Nibali Set to Win First Tour De France Raw: Shipwrecked Concordia Completes Last Voyage Raw: Sea Turtle Hatchlings Emerge From Nest Raw: Massive Dust Storm Covers Phoenix 12-hour Cease-fire in Gaza Fighting Begins Raw: Bolivian Dancers Attempt to Break Record Raw: Israel, Palestine Supporters Rally in US Raw: Air Algerie Flight 5017 Wreckage Virginia Governor Tours Tornado Aftermath Judge Faces Heat Over Offer to Help Migrant Kids Kangaroo Goes Missing in Oklahoma More M17 Bodies Return, Sanctions on Russia Grow
Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Poll

Should Madison County’s three local governing bodies ban smoking in indoor public places?

Yes
No
     View Results