The Richmond Register


November 28, 2012

Ex-RPD officers appeal federal court rulings in civil case

Appeal focuses on actions taken by Commonwealth’s Attorney’s office

RICHMOND — Two former RPD officers are appealing several rulings in a federal civil suit that accused local prosecutors and law enforcement officers of malicious prosecution in an attempt to convict them of witness tampering.

The appeal is focusing on whether the Madison Commonwealth’s Attorney and his assistant should have been granted immunity from civil prosecution for actions they took while investigating the criminal case against Garry Murphy and Brian Hensley.

U.S. District Judge Jennifer B. Coffman dismissed in June all federal claims brought in the suit against former Sheriff Nelson O’Donnell, the Madison County Sheriff’s Office, former sheriff’s deputy Scotty Anderson and Deputy Steve King.

The remaining claims against additional defendants were settled, and the case was dismissed with prejudice Sept. 21.

Investigators had accused James J. Rogers, Murphy and Hensley of forcing a woman, April McQueen, to change her story about what the officers said was a consensual sexual encounter she had with them Oct. 27, 2009.

A Madison County jury acquitted the three men in the criminal witness tampering case, and Murphy also was acquitted on a misdemeanor assault charge for allegedly striking McQueen in the face, causing a cut lip.

Murphy and Rogers were fired from the Richmond Police Department. Hensley resigned prior to an administrative hearing.

In an unrelated case, Rogers was convicted last month in federal court of receiving child pornography and sentenced to nine years in prison, which he is currently appealing. Rogers dropped out of the civil suit, leaving Murphy and Hensley to appeal the U.S. district judge’s rulings.

Last year, Coffman ruled in the civil case that Commonwealth’s Attorney David Smith and Assistant Commonwealth’s Attorney Jennifer Smith were entitled to immunity for their actions in investigating the case and presenting it to the grand jury.

The two men are focussing their appeal on actions taken by the Smiths. They are asking the appellate court to examine whether the prosecutors were entitled to immunity when they “procured false testimony and fabricated evidence during the criminal investigation,” according to the civil appeal statement of issues.

Murphy and Hensley argued in the original civil case that they were constitutionally deprived of liberty, but the U.S. district judge dismissed the malicious prosecution claim because the men were never arrested or jailed during the proceedings against them.

In the appeal, Murphy and Hensley are questioning whether incarceration or detention is required for them to have sustained a deprivation of liberty, according to the appeal issues document.

Finally, the men are asking whether “the district court commit (sic) error when it held that Kentucky state courts would analyze the immunity issues the same and dismissed Appellants’ state law claims ...”

David and Jennifer Smith are cross-appealing, asking the appellate court to reconsider the district court’s denial of their motion for attorney’s fees, according to the cross-appeal statement of issues.

The Smiths also wrote they were planning on arguing additional grounds in support of the U.S. district court’s final order, which stated Hensley and Murphy had failed to prove their claim of malicious prosecution under federal law.

The cross-appeal also asserts Jennifer Smith is entitled to absolute immunity for a meeting she had with McQueen on Nov. 12, 2009. Coffman ruled that Smith was entitled to qualified immunity in that instance but not absolute immunity.

Sarah Hogsed can be reached at or 624-6694.

Text Only
  • 4-23 Peter Crowe.jpg Intoxicated man charged with wanton endangerment

    A 27-year-old Richmond man was charged Sunday with second-degree wanton endangerment after he was found intoxicated and walking with several young children in the Keystone Drive area, according to a Richmond police report.

    April 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • Pot throwing downtown leads to arrest

    A Berea man was arrested Saturday after police say he damaged a downtown Richmond business and a parked vehicle by throwing flower pots.
    Jonathan A. McCullough, 34, was charged with first- and third-degree criminal mischief as well as alcohol intoxication, according to a Richmond police report.

    April 21, 2014

  • London police chief ordered to stay away from Berea woman

    A woman who who moved to Berea in February 2013 after a live-in relationship with London Police Chief Stewart O. Walker has obtained an emergency protective order against him from Madison Family Court.

    April 21, 2014

  • 4-19 Brian Smith.jpg Berea man indicted on 24 child porn counts

    A Madison grand jury has indicted a Berea man on 24 counts related to child pornography.

    Brian J. Smith, 26, is charged with four counts of distribution and 20 counts of possession of matter portraying sexual performances by a minor.

    April 19, 2014 1 Photo

  • 4-19 Gregory Powell.jpg Police apprehend burglary suspect

    An observant witness was able to help Richmond police catch a burglary suspect shortly after a break-in Thursday afternoon on Savanna Drive off Berea Road.

    April 19, 2014 1 Photo

  • CCDW instructor indicted on charges of failing to provide training

    A Madison County grand jury has indicted a carry-concealed weapons permit instructor on charges he falsely claimed to have provided instruction to one person for a CCDW permit and provided incomplete training to three others.
    Christopher D. Fins was indicted April 9 on one count of CCDW instructor not providing firearms training and three counts of providing incomplete firearms training.
    Fins faces up to 20 years in prison if convicted of all four felony charges.

    April 17, 2014

  • Sixth person charged in motel meth bust

    A sixth person has been charged in connection with a methamphetamine-making operation discovered last week at the Bel Air Motel in Richmond.
    Roger M. Million, 24, Moberly Road, was charged Wednesday with manufacturing methamphetamine.

    April 17, 2014

  • 4-18 George WilliamsWEB.jpg Madison County inmate dies in Lexington hospital

    An inmate at the Madison County Detention Center died Tuesday at a Lexington hospital, according to officials with the Fayette County Coroner’s Office and Madison County EMS.

    April 17, 2014 1 Photo

  • 4-17 Melissa Lear.jpg BPD charge two in Richmond heroin-trafficking case

    Berea police arrested two women April 10 in a Richmond home in connection with heroin possession and trafficking.

    April 16, 2014 1 Photo

  • 4-16 Lisa Begley.jpg Police: Woman drove through storage business gate

    Richmond police arrested a Lexington woman Monday night after the property manager at Main Street Storage said she repeatedly drove her vehicle into a gate and fence at the 455 E. Main St. business.

    April 16, 2014 1 Photo

AP Video
Bon Jovi Helps Open Low-income Housing in Philly Pipeline Opponents Protest on National Mall Hagel Gets Preview of New High-tech Projects S.C. Man Apologizes for Naked Walk in Wal-Mart New Country Music Hall of Fame Inductees Named 'Piles' of Bodies in South Sudan Slaughter New Yorkers Celebrate Cherry Blossom Blooms SCOTUS Hears Tv-over-Internet Case Justice Dept. Broadening Criteria for Clemency Chief Mate: Crew Told to Escape After Passengers 'Miss Meadows' Takes Holmes Back to Her Roots Biden: Russia Must Stop Talking, Start Acting David Moyes Out As Manchester United Manager Raw: Leopard Bites Man in India Iowa College Finds Beauty in Bulldogs High Court to Hear Dispute of TV Over Internet Stowaway Teen Forces Review of Airport Security
Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide

Should Richmond rezone the southwest corner of Main Street and Tates Creek Avenue to B-1 (Neighborhood Business) with restrictions to allow construction of a financial services office?

     View Results